As I have mentioned, my children are 4 and 2. They're old enough now to have Movie Night, and we curl up with popcorn and watch a movie on Fridays or Saturdays.
My dad sent us a copy of The Fox and the Hound, which I haven't seen in ages. And I'm coming to the conclusion that many kids movies have animal rights/vegetarian themes. It's weird really. These are movies made by adults, for children, and they undermine the very systems that the adults foist upon the kids as "normal." It's almost like the adults are trying to plant ideas that other adults are immune to, but children are open to.
The Fox and the Hound:In the first 5 minutes, the mama fox is carrying her baby and running from the hunter and his dogs. Then, she leaves the baby, snuzzles him goodbye, leads the hunter away from the baby and gets shot.
The skins of the animals that the hunter killed are shown as horrific and scary.
The hunter puts out leg hold traps to catch the fox, and later gets caught in one of his own traps, prompting me to educate my children on the concept of "poetic justice."
The whole movie is sympathetic to the fox, and the hunter is shown as a bit of a lunatic, shooting all over the place. However, at the end, the hunter spares the fox because the hound steps in front of him to defend him. So here, an individual animal is spared because of his "specialness," but other foxes who are not "special" will still be killed.
My poor son, sensitive soul that he is, was really agitated and wanted to turn it off during some of the more intense parts, like when the hunter hides behind a tree to shoot the terrified fox. My little daughter is starting to display empathy and was actually sad when the nice old lady (who rescued and raised the fox) had to take him out to the forest and let him go.
Chicken Run:
Ah, that famous line, "I don't want to be a pie!" Here we see chickens who don't want to be slaughtered plan their escape. My favorite part is the teeth.
Bambi:We haven't watched this one with the kids, partially because of Bambi's mom getting shot. I remember getting really upset when I was a kid. In time, we'll watch it. But again, we have the idea of the hunter being this monster who kills for no good reason.
Charlotte's Web:The new movie is coming out in December, and yes, I'll take my kids. How many vegans or vegetarians out there remember reading the story or seeing the movie and having something within you say that killing pigs was somehow not quite right? Then we buried it for awhile after our families told us that it was The Way Things Are.
Wilbur only escapes death because he moves out of the "pig" role to "pet" role. He'll be spared, but other pigs will not. So again we see this idea of a "special" animal being saved, because he's different from the rest of his kind.
Shark Tale:There's a shark who is a vegetarian. He's ridiculed by his family members, who try to make him be a "real" shark by making him eat fish. Adults can easily read it as an analogy for a young gay man in a family of "macho" men. But just as important is the idea of this compassionate shark who endures ridicule and ostracism to free worms, rescue fish, and aid the escape of a bunch of shrimp, because one is raising his orphaned nephew and needs to live to support his family.
The movie shows vegetarian shark as an effeminate and sentimental character, going with that old media favorite of vegetarianism being feminine and thus naturally inferior to the masculinity of killing animals. But the shark is a sympathetic character all the same.
Madagascar:
A lion, hippo, giraffe and zebra get stranded in The Wild. The lion doesn't know that steaks are made of animals, since he was raised in a zoo. As the days pass, the lion gets hungry and goes "crazy" and tries to eat his best friend, the zebra. He quarantines himself away, trying to keep himself from killing his friend. In the end, he ends up living on sushi. So again - animals are friends. Don't eat your friends. (Of course, we explained to the kids that lions must eat meat, so he can't just be an herbivore like his friends)
Finding Nemo:The sharks have this AA group to get them to not eat fish. They hold up their fins and recite, "fish are friends, not food." The humor of course is that sharks must eat fish, and one goes nuts when he gets a whiff of fish blood. But as always, there's this sympathy for the hunted fish - they're scared, they run, they escape, we cheer.
Babe:The cat tells Babe, "You see, animals that don't seem to have a purpose, really do have a purpose. The boss has to eat." And thus, Babe learns about The Way Things Are.
Kids feel happy when Babe becomes a sheep pig and is saved from being made into dinner. Just like Wilbur in Charlotte's Web, he accomplishes this by moving from "pig" role to "pet" role. He is spared because he is not like other pigs. This part sort of reinforces the idea that normal pigs are ok to kill because they're not "special."
At Christmas, the duck makes a terrible connection. "Christmas? Christmas means dinner. Dinner means death. Death means carnage. Christmas means carnage!" Sadly his duck friend Roseanna was killed for Christmas dinner. The part where the humans carve up Roseanna makes them look very creepy indeed.
The puppies tell Babe that pigs can't go in the house, not live ones anyway. And the mother dog assures them that people eating dogs is "ridiculous." But at this point in the movie, some people might ask themselves why.
When I first saw this movie, I liked the cute pig, but easily compartmentalized the idea of cute pig versus my bacon. Different things. I think most adults do this automatically, after years of practice. Kids don't have the practice, until we make them spend years deadening themselves to their own compassion for other creatures.
It's kind of a weird experiment we're doing on our kids. At least for me. I watch them respond to these ideas with confusion (why does the farmer want to eat the nice pig?), excitement (Nemo's daddy is getting away from the shark!) and horror (little foxes, run away from the hunter! run away from there!). I know "normal" kids respond the same way, but what happens when the adults don't tell them that it's ok to eat the pigs or shoot the foxes? What if we tell them not to hurt them even if they're not "special" or cute?
* * * * *
Even though some of these movies have the idea of the "special" animal being spared because he can move into the "pet" role in people's lives, these stories can also serve as a bridge between loving pets and loving "food" animals. If one animal is special or unique, maybe others are too, if only we look at them with different eyes.
I think the movies about a "special" animal can be read two ways: You can see it as justification to continue harming animals because the ones you hurt aren't special like the ones shown in these sentimental children's movies or books. Or you can make the connection between one special animal and many special animals.
It's interesting how adults almost always fall into the first category, but children fall into the second. And yet, adult filmmakers make these movies and adults take their children. It's as if there's something there in the adults, some desire to reconnect to the simple love they once had for all creatures. Maybe those adults know, deep down inside, that they still have the little seed in them, and hope to see it blossom in their children?
Now I'm going to quote a part from the
absolutely brilliant theme song, from the
Vegan Freak podcast which I am sadly very behind on listening to. Go, listen to the song and sing along. Go, listen to the podcast too, since it's always great. Also, visit the
Vegan Freak Forums. And
buy books.
When we were kids
the bugs and the birds fascinated us
They were just like us
Then we were taught to slam the door
It's not cool to feel too much
But some of us break free
According to you I'm a vegan freak
If that's what you think, I'm a vegan freak
That's your opinion I'm a vegan freak
Happy as Larry I'm a vegan freak.